More than 60 academic organisations in Germany and Austria have announced their decision to leave the messaging platform X, formerly known as Twitter. The withdrawal follows increasing concerns over the platform’s role in shaping political discourse and its alignment with principles of scientific and democratic integrity. The German government has also voiced apprehensions about the platform’s impact on public dialogue, citing its tendency to foster polarisation.
A Collective Move by Academia
The decision, announced on Friday, involves numerous prestigious universities and research institutions. In a joint statement, the organisations criticised X’s algorithms for undermining the principles of open-mindedness, transparency, and democratic discourse.
“The withdrawal is a consequence of the incompatibility of the platform’s current orientation with the fundamental values of the institutions involved: open-mindedness, scientific integrity, transparency, and democratic discourse,” the statement read.
The institutions pointed to the platform’s algorithmic tendencies to amplify right-wing populist content while restricting other viewpoints, making it untenable for the signees to continue using X as a communication tool.
Broader Discontent Among German Institutions
The exodus from X is not limited to academic institutions. Major trade unions, including GEW (representing educators and teachers) and Verdi, have already deleted their accounts. Even the Federal Court of Justice (BGH) has opted to depart from the platform, further highlighting the growing dissatisfaction among German public institutions.
German Government Weighs Options
On Friday, the German government confirmed that it is debating whether to maintain its presence on X. A government spokesperson highlighted the platform’s role in exacerbating political polarisation through its algorithms, which are perceived as fostering agitation rather than balanced dialogue.
However, the government remains on the platform for now, citing the need to reach a broad audience. The spokesperson dismissed claims that the government’s concerns were tied to Elon Musk’s direct involvement in German politics.
Musk’s Controversial Role
Elon Musk, the owner of X, has drawn criticism for his vocal support of the far-right Alternative for Deutschland (AfD) party. On Thursday, Musk hosted a live conversation on the platform with Alice Weidel, the AfD leader, during which he encouraged German voters to back the party in the upcoming elections. Musk has also used X to criticise leading German politicians, including Chancellor Olaf Scholz and President Frank-Walter Steinmeier.
These developments come ahead of critical elections in Germany, where political tensions are already high. Musk’s endorsement of the AfD and his platform’s alleged amplification of populist rhetoric have added fuel to the fire, raising concerns among political leaders and public institutions.
A Platform Under Scrutiny
Critics have long accused X of failing to address disinformation and hate speech. The European Commission is currently examining whether the platform complies with EU regulations governing social media networks. Musk’s support for controversial political figures, including his alignment with US President-elect Donald Trump, has further heightened scrutiny of his stewardship of X.
Implications for Political Discourse
The withdrawal of German academic and public institutions from X underscores a growing unease with the platform’s influence on public debate. By amplifying divisive content, critics argue, X is contributing to an increasingly polarised political landscape in Germany and beyond.
The decisions by German and Austrian organisations, coupled with the government’s ongoing deliberations, signal a broader reassessment of how public institutions engage with social media platforms. Whether this marks the beginning of a larger exodus remains to be seen, but the implications for X—and its owner—are significant.
Read also:
Alternative for Germany Calls for End to Russia Sanctions and EU Exit in Election Manifesto
